25 November 2025

A Homesick Thanksgiving 2025

Here is our annual Thanksgiving collection from the indefatigable and invaluable Dave Federman. Please read his touching essay, then find the link to his 32-song collection at the end.

Thanks, Dave - a happy holiday to you and to all!

Thanksgiving has long and maybe always been a national holiday that celebrates the peculiarly American longing for home. It has nothing to do with pilgrims and everything to do with pilgrimage. Its meaning lies in travel. Even in the most fractured families, members feel the need to travel back home or to invite family to their own for reunion. Hope springs eternal in these songs.

Going home has never been harder than it is now with air travel encumbered by massive traffic controller layoffs and shortages, plus severe aircraft age and safety problems. The skies have never seemed so unfriendly. And rail, the main alternate means of travel, has its own highly publicized problems.

So Thanksgiving 2025 has as much to do with yearnings for home as arrivals there. And these yearnings tap into deeper longings that are central to a nation that seems to have forgotten its refugee origins and relatively brief duration as a land of settlers. The natives, a good deal of whom were never really natives, are restless and want newer settlers banished. The dream of homecoming is suddenly more dream than reality.

This Thanksgiving has a kind of wartime quality to it. It’s as if we’re all on leave of duty and we can’t quite get to take that leave at home. Even many of those who make it home don’t feel at home when they get there. Maybe there’s too much uncertainty. Routes are no longer simple matters of maps and destinations. Once traveled to their end, many still feel a certain rootlessness. That rootlessness takes hold and intensifies the need to be home and truly thankful for lives more stressed and troubled than many of us haver eve known.

This medley acknowledges the homesickness gnawing at the hearts and hopes of many. Thanksgiving is no longer a cure for many who seek to celebrate it in its original contexts of reunion and gratitude. Many of the songs come from wartime and deal with yearnings for home and sentiments associated with them.

Strangely, four of the songs are Bing Crosby obscurities from either 1945 or 1950, both war years. Bing is America’s greatest troubadour of holiday songs. So how anthologists missed these recordings baffles me. His version of “Home Sweet Home” is the greatest I have ever heard and yet it is absent from every one of the numerous gatherings of his holiday recordings that I have found. Indeed, all of the four songs he sings have been denied candidacy for essential collections of his many holiday recordings. So, if this mix accomplishes nothing else, it gives the listener greater completeness of the incomparable Crosby corpus of holiday music.

A little past halfway, the music gets home and all sorts of iconic things give rise to music. But, again, much of the music has never been conscripted for holiday use. So here, too, the mix tries to remedy failure to include these recordings in CD collections or on streaming platforms at a time when they are needed most.

LINK

12 comments:

Keek said...

Thanks Dave, and Happy Thanksgiving to all.

Buster said...

And to you, Keek!

rev.b said...

Trusting the mix will every bit as insightful and poignant as the introduction. ‘Home’ does seem more inaccessible this year. Thank you Dave.

centuri said...

Happy Thanksgiving dear Buster !

Buster said...

rev.b - Hope you have a great holiday!

Buster said...

Thanks, Jean - may you have a wonderful holiday season as well!

Grover Gardner said...

Brilliant. Thanks Dave and Buster!

luckymike said...

What a moving essay and brilliant idea for a holiday share. Much to reflect on here, and some wonderful music to do it with. Thank you so much Dave and Buster, and whether one feels sad or happy, up or down as another holiday season comes at us, well, if you're reading this, you're here and that's sometimes enough. I'm sending a smile and a virtual hug to all the kindred spirits here who share our host's love of keeping a little bit of musical heritage alive. And if I'm weighing what I'm thankful for, then this project of yours and the daily joy it brings is high on the list, Buster.

Ernie said...

Happy Thanksgiving to you!

Buster said...

Happy Thanksgiving, Grover!

Buster said...

Thanks so much, mike - Happy Thanksgiving!

Buster said...

And to you, Ernie!