On the basis of artistic merit, it's hard to understand why. This is clearly one of the best vocal albums ever recorded. Allyn is in marvelous voice; he evidently had a great rapport with Mandel; the musicians were the best the West Coast had to offer.
For whatever reason, it didn't come out until 1978 on the Discovery label. The mastering was not good, however. I've significantly rebalanced matters and now it sounds great - to me, at least!
![]() |
| David Allyn |
As a bonus, I've appended a 1960 Guest Star transcription for U.S. Savings Bonds where David sings three songs - all of them also on this LP, although in different performances. Details down below.
Discographies date the Blue of Evening LP from the early 60s, which seems about right considering the song selection.
On the LP, for three songs, Allyn is accompanied by a small group - Jimmy Rowles, piano, Larry Bunker, vibes, Herb Ellis, guitar, Joe Mondragon, bass and Shelly Manne, drums. They appear on "Dream a Little Dream of Me," "Remind Me" and "It All Comes Back to Me Now."
The next group featured a French horn section with Conte Candoli, trumpet; Frank Rosolino, trombone; Bud Shank, Bob Cooper, Joe Maini, and Chuck Gentry, reeds; and the same rhythm section except for Mel Lewis on drums. The songs are "Down with Love." "That Old Devil Called Love" and "Cocktails for Two."
![]() |
| Johnny Mandel |
Mandel added strings and harp for the final grouping, which includes "In the Blue of Evening," "All Through the Day" and "And Now Goodbye."
Most of these songs are standards, with the possible exception of two. The first is "It All Comes Back to Me Now," one of my favorites. Alex Kramer, Joan Whitney and Hy Zaret wrote it in about 1940; David recorded it on one of his first sessions with Jack Teagarden's big band. You can find that version in this post devoted to Allyn's earliest recordings.
The second such song, "And Now Goodbye," is by David (music) and Steve Allen (lyrics). It's a very attractive number that should be better known.
Guest Star Transcription
The U.S. Treasury Department had a long-standing transcription series called Guest Star that it used to promote Savings Bonds. Allyn was a guest on a program distributed in 1960. The music director and producer of the series was former Phil Harris and Ozzie Nelson saxophonist Basil (Buzz) Adlam, who also worked on Ozzie's popular TV sitcom.David's selections with Adlam's very good group are "Dream a Little Dream of Me," "It All Comes Back to Me Now" and "It's a Pity to Say Goodnight." He's in excellent voice and does the numbers well; the latter better than the LP because he doesn't sound so besotted. He's stiff in the brief dialogues with announcer Lou Crosby, who is vaguely irritating. A very nice listen, however, and I've tracked it for you, so you can dispense with the superfluities.
FYI - You may note on the label above that Jo Stafford also had a Guest Star appearance on the same record. Unlike Allyn's program, her songs were taken from commercial recordings.
LINK to In the Blue of Evening and Guest Star














