04 September 2016

Bach Cantatas from Mack Harrell, Robert Shaw, Marc Lifschey and the Clevelanders

This post continues my survey of recordings by the Szell-era Cleveland Orchestra under other conductors and different names. Previously we have heard from long-time Szell associate Louis Lane. Today the maestro is the famed choral conductor Robert Shaw in performances taped early in his spell as associate conductor and chorus director in Cleveland (1956-1967).

Shaw, shortly before
his Cleveland appointment
Although Cleveland is not mentioned anywhere on the packaging, it is likely that this record of two Bach cantatas involves both members of the orchestra and its chorus. When it was recorded (May 1958), Shaw was an RCA Victor artist. The orchestra, however, was under contract to Epic Records and could not be identified as such for this RCA disc. In any case, Shaw uses a relatively small complement of instrumentalists, so the issue is not a major one, save for the presence of Cleveland Orchestra oboist Marc Lifschey, who is credited with the important obbligato solo in BWV 56 ("Ich will den Kreuzstab gerne tragen"), and is certainly also the uncredited soloist in the opening aria of BWV 82 ("Ich habe genug").

Marc Lifschey
I make a point of this because as far as I can tell, this is the only credited solo on record by Lifschey, principal oboe from 1950-65 save for one year, and a musician who was revered by other orchestra members. [Correction: Lifschey is also credited on the Mozart Divertimento K131 recording of 1963 - thanks to Derek Katz for sending a note about this!]

The oboist is repeatedly cited in the recent book of anecdotes about the orchestra under Szell, Tales from the Locker Room, assembled by longtime principal bass Lawrence Angell, who himself remarked, "The sound that came from [Lifschey's] oboe was often a miracle; so miraculous it astounded his colleagues." Said violinist Michael Goldman, "He was the soul of the orchestra. I got chills up and down my spine when he played." And fellow oboist Eldon Gatwood said, "I have never heard such a musical line," a particularly appropriate observation considering Lifschey's playing here.

But I am neglecting the principals in this recording, Shaw and baritone Mack Harrell, who is front and center in these cantatas: BWV 56 has but one chorale, and BWV 82 is entirely solo. Harrell's singing is flawless. He is a baritone tackling these cantatas for bass voice, but there is no sense of strain, with the voice always beautifully produced.

Mack Harrell
This production came late in Harrell's career - he died at age 50 in 1960, shortly before this LP was issued. It marked his second recording of BWV 56; he had done it as early as 1939 under Edward van Beinum in Amsterdam. Harrell's son Lynn, the famed cellist, was principal in the Cleveland Orchestra for several years in the 60s and 70s.

Robert Shaw had joined the Cleveland conducting staff in 1956, and was already a star in the choral universe. He had founded the Robert Shaw Chorale in 1948 and had produced many LPs of both pop and classical music for RCA, while preparing choirs for Arturo Toscanini and the NBC Symphony. Following his Cleveland tenure, Shaw would go on to become the music director of the Atlanta Symphony for more than two decades.

Cover of original issue
Virtually all Shaw's Victor recordings are credited to the Shaw Chorale - but not this one. My supposition is that he used singers from the Cleveland Orchestra Chorus for this coupling of two mainly solo cantatas.

Michael Gray's discography has the recording taking place in St. Paul's Church, Cleveland; presumably this is St. Paul's Episcopal Church in Cleveland Heights, site of many concerts by orchestra-related groups. The sound is quite good. My transfer is from the Victrola reissue.

16 comments:

Buster said...

Link (Apple lossless):

https://mega.nz/#!XB1HESJa!axurBmwFZrS-uF_1flZNT0WmlR7gnLHUfdwVm5kHuvM

Jim said...

Lovely. Thank you.

Buster said...

Jim - You are welcome!

Buster said...

Marty - You're always welcome!

hkitt42 said...

I've always found George Szell and the Clevelanders unsurpassed in what I view as the core 18th century-early 19th century repertoire: principally Bach, Mozart, Haydn, Beethoven, Mendelssohn et al.

Others, I know, prefer a more sweeping, romantic approach to this music (e.g., Bruno Walter) I prefer the combination of musicality, crispness and precision of Szell and the Cleveland Orchestra: the late sypmhonies of Mozart and Haydn; Mozart's piano concertos with Cadasus and/or Serkin; the Beethoven symphony and piano concerto cycles (the latter with Leon Fleisher.

Accordingly, I was quite surprised to learn that The Clevelanders recorded Bach cantatas, which I don't normally associate with them or Szell. I've enjoyed many of Shaw's cantata recordings, particularly those with Russell Oberlin, a true countertenor, not a falsettist. I'd be interested to learn if additional Shaw/Cleveland recordings exist.

Many thanks, as always.

Howard

hkitt42 said...

PS I realized I misspelled Robert Cadasesus

Oops!

Buster said...

hkitt - Thanks for your comment(s)! I don't believe there are other Cleveland Orchestra commercial recordings with Shaw as conductor (as opposed to choral director). I should mention that my attribution of this recording to that ensemble is informed speculation.

Contraboy said...

Thank you very much for this! Is Marc Lifschey the oboe soloist for the Szell/Cleveland recording of the Mozart Divertimento, K. 131?

Buster said...

Contraboy - Very likely. That was recorded in 1963, which would have been before he left the orchestra.

punkinblue9 said...

Thank you!

Buster said...

Re: the Mozart Divertimento - I have confirmed by looking at the original Epic issue that Lifschey is indeed credited as oboe soloist.

dave_bruce said...

Thanks v much for this - every bit as good as your comments suggest. At least to my untutored ears, the style sounds so undated.

thedentist said...

Thanks for this treat. Downloaded and will be listening soon. Am I the first to note that in the listing in the artist column it says Mark Harrell instead of Mack!! Oops...

Phillip said...

What a treat, Buster. Thank you so much.

Muff Diver said...


Thank you Buster. I'll be listening soon!

Steve Waldee said...

Buster:

Excellent job, as usual! Much appreciated; I've never had this famous LP.

I had the pleasure of meeting Mr. Shaw when he conducted the Berlioz Requiem in SF many years ago: a very workmanlike performance from a fine gentleman, but he was getting on--it did not have Scherchen's inimitable fire, for sure!

Speaking of Shaw, here's my contribution: the 1947 RCA Victor recording of the Brahms Requiem.

I got the original transfer from a certain now-defunct blog that shall remain NAMELESS. The proprietor was a nice fellow with impeccable musical understanding, but NO competence whatsoever with technical issues related to transfers: his uploads had barely any highs above 4 kHz (but I found that since many of the files were lossless, I could actually recover the upper partials without too much in the way of side-effects.) I believe he may have used one of those cheap-n-dirty phono cartridge to USB adaptors, and it surely did NOT have proper RIAA or NAB equalization!

I reworked this radically, not only to recover his 'missing' highs but also to try to undo the savage 1947 RCA Victor audio compression. (I may have even added a tiny bit of reverb; I cannot quite recall!)

No doubt a really PURE transfer from an authentic Red Seal LP *could* possibly sound better--but you'd still have that AWFUL peak limiting and narrow dynamic range! Shame on me, but I'm not *always* a sonic purist if the old recording hurts my ears...

File will expire in 30 days, so get it while it's hot!

https://www74.zippyshare.com/v/2FrhlP9b/file.html

(249 MB, lossless FLACs)

Buster: if you like this or any other little items I've occasionally added to your blog comments, feel free to appropriate and repost without any credit to me!

Best,
8h haggis