As with Halloween, I had to turn to Internet Archive's depleted but still bountiful collection for most of my source material.
This first post will concern itself with the concept of thanksgiving, broadly stated. The only item that deals directly with the American holiday is a children's record designed for use in the schoolroom. Ironically, some of the other content comes from England, which does not celebrate the holiday.
The second post, which will follow soon, is about the functional meaning of the holiday: food! (And beer!)
![]() |
| Irving Aaronson and His Commanders |
Today's first item has the promising title of "Let's Be Thankful." But upon further examination, it's not about the holiday but rather it's one of the many cheery, chin-up songs of the Depression era. It's from 1934 and Irving Aaronson and His Commanders, an American radio band.
Next we take a sharp turn into an elementary-school classroom of the 1950s, and a programmatic recording that actually is about American Thanksgiving. Such records were designed for young children to join in; the packaging provides a lesson plan for the teacher. The selections are "Family's Thanksgiving," "I Am Thankful," "Long, Long Ago and Indian Dance" and "Faith of Our Fathers," taking the children back to the Pilgrim era. I remember enduring lessons like this as a tot. The download includes instructions should you wish to enlist your Thanksgiving guests in the pagentry.
![]() |
| Delbert Barker |
The Pilgrims were, of course, exiles from England, who first went to the Netherlands (where Thanksgiving actually is celebrated) and then to the New World. In their honor, we have the gospel song "I Am a Pilgrim," first anthologized in the mid-19th century, and then taken up by both gospel groups and country musicians. In this case, we have a 1953 budget release by the excellent Delbert Barker, who I believe is covering a Merle Travis record. Barker was Kentucky-born but based in Cincinnati at the time. He later made early rockabilly records for King. This record deals with the concept of "pilgrim" as a seeker of heaven, rather than specifically the Pilgrims.
Next we have a set of three recordings from England, one from the 1935 Silver Jubilee Thanksgiving Service honoring King George V, and two giving thanks for the end of World War II.
![]() |
| A contemporary painting of the Silver Jubilee Service by Frank O. Salisbury |
The Silver Jubilee record is taken from the service in St. Paul's Cathedral by the Cathedral Choir directed by Sir Stanley Marchant. The selection is Gustav Holst's setting of "I vow to thee my country" to the familiar music of the "Jupiter" movement from The Planets. The words are by Cecil Spring Rice.
We move ahead 10 years almost to the day and the same site for a Thanksgiving Service a few days after the end of the war in Europe. The congregation sings the hymn "Now thank we all our God."
To mark the end of the war, Ralph Vaughan Williams wrote a work initially called "Thanksgiving for Victory," later retitled "A Song of Thanksgiving." We have the 1951 recording from soprano Betty Dolemore, the Luton Choral Society and the London Philharmonic, directed by Sir Adrian Boult. It's a substantial and affecting work.
![]() |
| King Palmer, Ronald Binge |
Staying in England, we have two library recordings from notable composers. The first is "Thanksgiving" by Ronald Binge, which is very Elgarian. Second is "Quiet Thanksgiving" by Cedric King Palmer, a prolific contributor to these royalty-free collections. Both are brief, but enjoyable pieces of light music.
For our penultimate item, we reach back to 1923 and the Jolly Companions (the Victor Band under another name) for a lively "Thanksgiving Polka." This was apparently aimed at the ethnic market - on the label, the title was translated into Italian, German, Czech and Polish. The German and Czech titles refer to a church holiday, but this is, as the title portends, dance music. Nathaniel Shilkret wrote the piece and leads the band.
Finally, here is the first 12 minutes of the Elgin Watch Company's 1948 Thanksgiving Day radio show, "Two Hours of Stars." This snippet gives you Don Ameche, Mario Lanza, Jimmy Durante and too much Garry Moore. It comes from an amateur transcription that made announcer Ken Carpenter sound like he had inhaled helium. I've slowed it down and it now sounds good.
Back soon with the banquet (and beer).







