24 June 2024

Ezio Pinza Sings and Sells

After a career on the opera stage, bass Ezio Pinza (1892-1957) moved on to films, Broadway and the recording studio in the postwar years. Today's post is devoted to that late period in his career. We have five LPs - an expanded version of Ezio Pinza Sings "Enchanted Melodies", a promotional record for Magnavox from about 1956, and remastered versions of Ezio Pinza in Opera, Broadway and Hollywood and the LPs from Pinza's films Mr. Imperium and Tonight We Sing.

Ezio Pinza Sings "Enchanted Melodies"


I first posted this 10-inch record 15 years ago, but decided that it warranted a new transfer. My pithy comments back then were that the LP makes reference to Pinza's big hit "Some Enchanted Evening" in its title without actually including the song. Instead this 1950 album resurrects some items that Pinza had recorded for Columbia at various times in the 1940s.

I wrote, "In truth, it makes an attractive if not enchanted program, and gives the singer ample opportunity to display all his best qualities. The cover is by Alex Steinweiss, who thought that Pinza would look good with green skin and teeth."

Nor were the reviewers back then entirely enchanted by the program. One called the Fleger and Holmès songs "hardy veterans of the women's club recital circuit." But the opera excerpts were met with acclaim: regarding the Rossini aria, one reviewer gushed "at no time that I can remember was he more subtle in conveying the meaning of the words" and "The voice is mellow, round and luscious." The accompanist in the songs is Gibner King, who worked with Pinza for many years.

Mary Martin and Ezio Pinza in South Pacific
In addition to the eight selections on the LP, I have added six additional songs from the same period - including "Just a Kiss Apart" from Gentlemen Prefer Blondes and "Bali Ha'i," which Pinza did not sing in South Pacific, but which Columbia had him record anyway. He did of course sing "Some Enchanted Evening," and I have made up for Columbia's oversight in compiling the Enchanted Melodies album by including it in this augmented package.

The LP is from my collection; the extras are courtesy of Internet Archive. The sound is very good in ambient stereo.

LINK to new transfer and bonuses

"I Hear Music . . . " (Magnavox Promo)


In late 1955 or early 1956, the Magnavox high-fidelity people hired Pinza to narrate a record of selections from the RCA Victor catalog while touting the many virtues of the equipment. The excerpts included orchestral works conducted by Toscanini, Reiner, Fiedler and Stokowski, and opera arias with Cellini and Perlea accompanying leading voices of the time. The Stoky selection is his peculiar Beethoven Pastoral Symphony with actual sounds of nature added to the orchestral effects the composer had written.

Florence Henderson and Ezio Pinza - opening night of Fanny
Pinza himself is heard in his solo from the Broadway musical Fanny (music and lyrics by Harold Rome), which ran from late 1954 to late 1956. It certainly is not the best thing Pinza ever sang; the music is unremarkable and the lyrics were perhaps suggested by Goodnight Moon, which was published several years earlier. Well, at least Pinza's last act was a great success.

In addition to the record, which was provided to buyers of Magnavox equipment, Pinza appeared at magazine ads for both the company's hi-fi sets and its televisions. The example below is from late 1955.

About two-thirds of the way through the record, either RCA ran out of excerpts or Pinza ran out of things to say. He then turns things over to George Melachrino and his strings, who play five selections without commentary. 

Back in 1954, RCA had inaugurated its LPM series of 12-inch popular LPs by releasing seven Melachrino albums, all but one with the title beginning "Music for ...", including such gems as "Music for Faith and Inner Calm" and "Music for Courage and Confidence." The series culminated in "Music to Help You Sleep," which sums up the soporific effect of the Melachrino manner. The Magnavox selections are drawn from this series.

Some of the Melachrino LPs were expanded versions of previously released 10-inch albums. I suspect that the Magnavox promo itself was originally intended to be a 10-incher, then was inflated to 12 inches at the last minute, necessitating including the "Music for" excerpts.

This curiosity is from my collection. It was apparently owned by someone who couldn't afford another record after buying the pricey Magnavox console, and so played it so much it became remarkably noisy. I've managed to remove 99 percent of the crackle, so the sound is now reasonably good. This comes from my collection.

LINK to Magnavox promo LP

Ezio Pinza in Opera, Broadway and Hollywood 

RCA Victor took over Pinza's recording contract from Columbia in 1950 or 1951, and this LP is among the first fruits of that new partnership. I posted it in 2011, noting that the bass's career as a Hollywood leading man began with Strictly Dishonorable, where he plays to type as an amorous opera star.

"There is no soundtrack album from Strictly Dishonorable," I wrote, "but this RCA Victor 10-inch LP from 1951 includes an aria from Gounod's Faust that Pinza sings in the film, although this is not the same version. Otherwise, the LP is split down the middle between Pinza's operatic repertoire and pop songs. He is in fine voice for all, but is more comfortable with the operatic material. His phrasing in the pop songs is foursquare, and he sounds under rehearsed. Only in 'The Way You Look Tonight' does he go below the surface, and in that he captures some of the ardor that made him so magnetic in South Pacific."

I've now remastered the LP in ambient stereo, and edited the original article to include a few photos of Pinza in Faust and The Marriage of Figaro.

LINK to original post

Mr. Imperium

Pinza's second film was Mr. Imperium: "Once again playing to type, Pinza is a playboy prince who becomes romantically entangled with singer Lana Turner," I wrote in 2011.

The songs from the film include a few by Harold Arlen and Dorothy Fields - "My Love and My Mule" is not their best work, I'd say. But then there is Augustin Lara's wonderful "You Belong to My Heart," so that helps matters.

On the LP, the Turner numbers are taken by RCA contractee Fran Warren, although Trudy Erwin dubbed them for the film. You can hear Erwin's work in the recent comprehensive post devoted to her, including a song that I strongly suspect was slated for the film but not used.

The original post of Mr. Imperium also has been augmented with new photos, with the sound thoroughly overhauled and now in ambient stereo.

LINK to original post

Tonight We Sing

Pinza's final film was 1952's Tonight We Sing. Here's how I described the proceedings when I first wrote about in in 2010: "The film is a biopic on impresario Sol Hurok. Why anyone would want to watch a movie about a concert promoter is beyond me - I guess it was just a way to string together musical sequences featuring Hurok's attractions such as Ezio Pinza and Roberta Peters. That's them acknowledging the unseen audience on the cover above as Jan Peerce looks on from the prompter's box. (Poor Peerce didn't actually get into the film, although his voice did.)"

Pinza as Chaliapin, mink and all 

This LP does include the songs directly from the soundtrack, which include Gounod and Puccini arias, along with some Mussorgsky, necessary because Pinza was playing his basso predecessor Feodor Chaliapin, who specialized in Boris Godunov. Back in 2010 I commented that the film made the bass look like a blustering fool. Someone wrote in to point out that Chaliapin was, in fact, a blustering fool. 

You don't have to wade through the film, of course, to enjoy the singing on this effective LP. Once again, the sound has been completely updated and is now in ambient stereo.

LINK to original post

15 comments:

JAC said...

Since the poster advertises "the voice of Jan Peerce," I'm assuming the movie's credits do so as well. This upsets my previous assumption that South Pacific (5 years later) was the first movie to openly acknowledge the use of a singing double (Giorgio Tozzi in that case, of course). There had been a tradition of keeping such things secret. I suppose it was deemed less important in a case like this when the onscreen "singer" wasn't someone being developed as a star. Or are there still earlier instances that I don't know about?

Buster said...

JAC - I believe there are, at least in the pop realm. Some of the ones that come to mind are special cases: Jane Froman dubbing Susan Hayward in her biopic With a Song in My Heart. Bing Crosby dubbed Eddie Bracken in Out of This World, then the Bowery Boys stole the idea for Blues Busters, having Crosby-clone John Laurenz dub Huntz Hall. M-G-M did occasionally credit dubbers, but not that I can recall for opera or operetta. (I could be wrong.)

Yes, the film did credit Peerce with dubbing Byron Palmer, the little remembered romantic lead in the film.

Buster said...

Addendum - I'm preparing a post that includes a few recordings that should have been dubbed: Ava Gardner in Pandora and the Flying Dutchman and Susan Hayward in I'll Cry Tomorrow.

JAC said...

I probably overgeneralized from cases in which the studio famously tried to hide the use of dubbers. Like Marni Nixon in The King and I (for which Deborah Kerr eventually revealed all herself, in a spirit of fairness). Or the fact that dancing stars like Rita Hayworth, Cyd Charisse, and Vera-Ellen were never allowed to sing for themselves onscreen (though they'd all sung onstage or would eventually do so; but they didn't have the tone quality the studios wanted for "their girls").

Your proposed post sounds interesting; I look forward to it. Ava Gardner was able to split the difference in Show Boat: dubbed onscreen, but her own voice on the "soundtrack" LP.

Buster said...

I have an interest in dubbing artists, having devoted posts to Jo Ann Greer and Trudy Erwin (not necessarily of their dubs). I have a extensive set of Anita Ellis recordings that I will post as soon as I get the energy to write about them. (There are 60 some songs.)

JAC said...

Ah, Anita Ellis is a very interesting case. And did Martha Mears ever make any records?

Buster said...

Yes, Ellis is one of the singers who rated a credit from M-G-M. Martha Mears did make some records, yes, although I'm not so sure how many.

Come to think of it, I've also posted dubbing artists Pat Friday and Jeri Sullivan.

gimpiero said...

Great

coppinsuk said...

Magnificent in every way. Clearly demonstrates enthusiasm and oodles of diligent research which results in much knowledge and information making an interesting offering.

Many, many thanks.

Cheers,

Douglas, Shropshire, UK.

Buster said...

Thanks, gimpiero!

Buster said...

Thank you, Douglas! Your comments are much appreciated.

Carrington Dixon said...

Back in the 1950s there was a 90-minutes radio show called "The Big Show". This show featured a variety of performers each week. In many cases we heard performers that did not usually work together. Groucho and Fanny Brice together were not particularly funny, but Groucho and Ezio Pinza together were hilarious.

Buster said...

Carrington - Fascinating. I do remember network radio, although barely. Groucho and Ezio sound like a great pair!

centuri said...

Many thanks for this collection featuring a real and multi-faceted musician, as well as for the AS -improvements of the sound.

Buster said...

Hi Jean - Thanks so much! Hope you enjoy this mixed bag of Pinza.