27 March 2018

The Popular Gershwin / Gershwin on Holiday

A little over three years ago, I offered a 1955 Morton Gould collection called "The Serious Gershwin," which collated most of that composer's concert works. When that two-record set came out, RCA Victor issued a companion box called "The Popular Gershwin." Now my great friend Ernie has come up with the pop set and is presenting it here for us to enjoy.

But that's not all (as they say in the cheezy commercials). Ernie also has found a 1963 RCA collection called "Gershwin on Holiday," once again proferring the composer's popular songs as interpreted by the label's leading artists.

Let me give you the lineups for each set. "The Popular Gershwin" includes numbers by Eddie Fisher, the Sauter-Finegan Orchestra, the Melachrino Strings, Hugo Winterhalter, Jaye P. Morgan, Henri René, June Valli, Lou Monte, Frankie Carle, Glenn Miller and Dinah Shore. Neither Ernie nor I have had to motivation to check to see if any of these were newly recorded for the set, but we suspect they came from existing masters, collated for this purpose. Parenthetically, I believe the Glenn Miller songs come from the circa 1940 Chesterfield radio broadcasts that RCA were releasing at the time.

The singing ranges from superb (Dinah) to sub-optimal (Lou Monte, who should have stuck to the "Italian Jingle Bells" and the like). The instrumentalists are generally fine, although I can take or leave Frankie Carle.

Perhaps surprisingly, not too many of the 1955 RCA artists remained for the 1963 collection - just Carle and Winterhalter. They are joined by the always-welcome Morton Gould, Al Hirt, Norman Luboff, Peter Nero and the Three Suns - so a much heavier emphasis on instrumentals, with no solo vocalists represented. Unlike the 1955 set, the 1963 recordings are in stereo.

"The Popular Gershwin" has a much more attractive cover, although plopping the long-dead Gershwin down in a what is evidently a contemporary rehearsal seems a little odd. Not as odd as the hat he is wearing on the cover of "A Gershwin Holiday," though.

As always, Ernie coaxed good sound from these old items, and he is a demon for documentation, providing scans not only of the cover, but the record sleeves, labels, and the inside of the "Gershwin Holiday" gatefold. He did not scan all of the "Popular Gershwin" booklet, noting that it is the same as the one that I posted with "The Serious Gershwin." [Edit: Both Ernie and I mis-remembered. I didn't scan the booklet, so please don't go to the earlier post looking for it!]

Thanks once again to Ernie for his work on this. Ernie is a Christmas specialist, but lately he has been posting the occasional non-Christmas item on his blog, including a really good Henri René LP.

20 comments:

Buster said...

Links:

The Popular Gershwin
https://mega.nz/#!PB1kATII!_3yREKeFFh5Ui3MoWOxnT-0UVp2wLq7xBDokhBPGtTo

Gershwin on Holiday
http://www10.zippyshare.com/v/AqySo49r/file.html

rev.b said...

My Gershwin cup runneth over! Thanks for all of these Buster.

Ernie said...

Aww, shucks! Thanks, Buster, just trying to keep up with you. I was pretty sure you wouldn't post A Gershwin Holiday because it had The Three Suns on there. I wasn't too excited by that one, but my favorite track on The Popular Gershwin has to be Wintergreen For President. Next time I see that soundtrack/cast recording, I'm going to have to pick it up and check it out.

DonHo57 said...

My Mom was an early member of the RCA Record Club, and as a concert pianist by training she often leaned toward light albums like this since it was Gershwin. The Gershwin Holiday LP was a staple in our record cabinet and was my earliest introduction to Gershwin. I enjoy having a clean copy of it, and will have to play it for Mom this weekend. Thanks, Buster.

Buster said...

rev.b and Don - All thanks to our pal Ernie for this one!

Ernie - For Of Thee I sing here's an early 50s recording with Jack Carson, and a 1987 version with Larry Kert that I can recall.

Ernie said...

I take back what I said about no good stuff on the Gershwin Holiday records. I think I like the Peter Nero stuff. Not what I expected at all!

alfred venison said...

thank you both very much. -cheers, a.v.

centuri said...

Thanks a million Buster for these incredible journeys:
fascinating also to compare different arrangements of same titles, all bringing different aspects of Gershwin's music.
Would love to hear more of Hugo Winterhalter (from memory I remember an excellent Rhapsody in Blue coupled with Grofé's exceprts)...
May I ask you to update the link of your Henri René post...Thanks in advance.

Buster said...

centuri - Sure, will do on the René post - may take me a little while.

Boursin said...

Hooray!

But what is described as "insert" is the front and back covers of what I seem to recall as an LP-sized booklet of approximately 20 pages (I haven't seen a physical copy of either 1955 Gershwin set for a long time). Is this so, and can the inside pages perhaps be supplied?

Buster said...

Boursin - See the note above in the article:

He did not scan all of the "Popular Gershwin" booklet, noting that it is the same as the one that I posted with "The Serious Gershwin." So you can get it there if you are interested - the set is still available via this post.

Link is above.

Boursin said...

Hmmm! While admittedly not reading the post above all the way through, I did make sure to click through to your earlier post on the Serious set and download that one as well. But the booklet's not included in the Serious G zip file available at both Mega and Mediafire – only the music itself and the cover of the box.

Buster said...

Boursin - You are right - both Ernie and I thought I had scanned it. I apparently thought it was more trouble than it was worth at the time. I'll change the text above.

Buster said...

Reup link for Henri René -

https://mega.nz/#!HclDCIQT!tIS-MC6CUeYNwncJfAlrW885XrXz1n3Mf_CQ13JDQEE

Ernie said...

Yeah, it's a whole lot of book, that didn't really seem worth the trouble.

barba said...

i was hoping for a couple of cha-cha-cha versions from hugo. but i guess you can't have everything. good stuff. thanx.


winterhalter for presidennnt...cha-cha-cha

Phillip said...

This is a treat. Many thanks to you both.

Peter said...

Many thanks - it is a treat indeed!

jeronimo said...

Buster man, thanks for the 3 links included in this post. Appreciated :)

j.

Scoredaddy said...

how did I miss this? belated thanks