The Rubinstein work has the dubious distinction of being of being perhaps the best-known of the "forgotten" Romantic war-horse concertos. Seldom if ever performed live, it has nonetheless been the subject of at least 10 commercial recordings, beginning with this March 1952 date with Dimitri Mitropoulos and the New Yorkers. It was followed in just a few months by a Friedrich Wührer session in Vienna for Vox.
![]() |
Caricature by David Levine |
As a bonus I've included two pieces from the pianist's 1955 Liszt collection - the Sonetto del Petrarca No. 104 and the Valse Oubliée No. 1 in F-sharp Minor. My transfer comes from the 1960s Odyssey reissue of the Rubinstein concerto, where they were included as filler. (The 1955 LP, which I do not own, also included a selection of Hungarian Rhapsodies.)
For the Rubinstein, I transferred the first two movements from the original pressing, and switched to the reissue for the third movement because of groove damage on the earlier disc. The first issue is marginally more present in sound, but there isn't much difference, and overall the sonics are excellent, as is often the case with recordings from Columbia's 30th Street Studios in New York.
What is that cover supposed to represent? I've been staring at it for ten minutes and I'm still at a loss. Light bulbs? Pen nibs? Those objects are clearly meant to be something against a sheet of blank music paper, but what? Is this a Steinweiss? The art is clearly more interesting to me than the music. :)
ReplyDeleteErnie - They are piano hammers, I believe:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.pianoren.com/site/largepics/754/63615/251518/348376/piano_hammers.JPG
The cover art is from Monogram, although it has a Steinweiss feel to it.
Thanks!
ReplyDeleteWell, that at least makes some sense. I wouldn't have gotten that. Thanks for straightening me out. :)
ReplyDeleteMany thanks Buster for this historical document completing beautifully the Levant collection. This piano concerto deserves to be more known !
ReplyDeleteLooking forward to this. Thanks Buster.
ReplyDeleteBuster,
ReplyDeleteGood recording. I have been following your listings of Oscar Levant recordings. Previously, I had known him primarily for his movie work, where he exuded a clownish persona, and thus never took him seriously as a musician. Levant certainly performs the Rubinstein concerto very well. It is a shame this concerto is so neglected, as it one of the best piano concertos of the 19th century. I have two other recordings of this piece (Banowetz and Hamelin), and Levant’s rendition does not take a back seat to either of those great pianists.
I should also mention a couple of other recent listings of yours that I found of great interest. The incidental music from “Flowering Peach” and the ballet suite “Is There Survival” are two of the more attractive pieces of this uneven composer. I was unfamiliar with this music beforehand, so I thank you for that. Also, I should mention your re-up of ”New Music from Old Erin”. I just loved the album. I had noticed this listing before, but unfortunately, the link was dead, so I was real glad when you re-upped it. I had gotten to know Seoirse Bodley music from the recording of his Symphony 4 & 5 on the Marco Polo label. His Music for Strings also impresses. The music of Brian Boydell & Frederick May were new to me, so I appreciate your making this recording available. Thank you so much for your wonderful blog.
centuri and rev.b - Thanks so much!
ReplyDeletePurcell - Thanks to you as well! I've had a recording of the Rubinstein since the Raymond Lewenthal version came out around 1970. I don't usually make comparisons, but the Levant is at least as good, I think.
I too liked the Old Erin record; I wish I had the other volume in the series.
the only Levant I really know well is Gershwin music. thanks for the opp to hear more@!!
ReplyDeleteOutstanding post, Buster! I think this recording qualified as the first of any extended work by Anton Rubinstein. I've loved this Levant recording since having that Odyssey LP in the early 70s. I still have it somewhere, but God only knows where it is....
ReplyDeleteHi there...I've been a fan of your blog for a few years. I also happen to be classical music critic of the Philadelphia Inquirer and am writing a fun summer piece on music that time forgot. May I mention your blog and talk about how much fun it is? I don't want to get you into any copyright trouble (I think your postings are all public domain) so if you want me to keep quiet, I will. Thanks!
ReplyDeleteHi David,
ReplyDeleteSo pleased to hear that you like the blog. I do try to stay under the radar because the issue of what is in the public domain is a confusing one. However, I would very much like to be mentioned in your column. Would you mind letting me know what you might say so that I can see whether it would be problematic? If that is too much trouble, I understand and thank you for your interest!
In any case, I would be very curious to find out what you like the most, least and so on. My email is busterooni@gmail.com.
Buster
Basically, the column is about reversing the hunter/gatherer equation of music collecting. Instead of hunting down what you think you want, you see what comes your way that you don't know that you want, whether it's CDs left in rental cars, stuff in flea markets or in blogs such as yours that cast a very wide net as far as musical genres are concerned. Would it be helpful if I said your contents are in public domain (and I do believe they are)? You and I have similar tastes; sometimes I'll look at your blog and think, "Oh, I thought I was the only one who had that." Mostly, I like to download things I know little about, such as the Lisa Kirk single on your other blog....
ReplyDeleteFamous!!! :)
ReplyDeleteDavid - That sounds wonderful. Many thanks!
ReplyDeleteErnie - At last!!!
Great post Buster! Thank you.
ReplyDeleteGreat find, Rubinstein's 4th is one of those concertos where the finale is bound to get the audience clapping.
ReplyDeleteDear Buster, The link provided for this leads to an empty zip file. Any chance of a re-up? Many thanks! - Thorlief
ReplyDeleteThorlief - I wonder what Mediafire did with it. Let me find the files and reup.
ReplyDeleteNew link (Apple lossless):
ReplyDeletehttps://mega.nz/file/bZt3SZbA#eCS4f4ZzpaLH6GR0Uw4efOSSrBS-KPYiroaI2BF88OY
Thanks again!
ReplyDelete