Menotti and Honegger Led by Munch

This post is notable for Gian Carlo Menotti's neglected violin concerto. Not that I am shrugging off Arthur Honegger's second symphony, but this recording has been reissued repeatedly, unlike the Menotti work.

This was the first and for many years the only recording of the concerto, written in 1952 for Efrem Zimbalist. By the time this version was set down in November 1954, the work had also been taken up by Tossy Spivakovsky, who is heard here with Charles Munch and the Boston Symphony.

This is a beautiful concerto in a vibrant rendition. It is surprising that both the concerto and the recording are not better known.

Munch recorded the symphony at least three times. Honegger completed the work in 1942, and Munch took the Paris Conservatoire Orchestra into the studio that same year to begin work on a recording, which for some reason was not completed until 1944. This reading is from March 1953.

Honegger scored his symphony for strings with a prominent trumpet part in the final movement, presumably played here by Roger Voisin, longtime BSO principal.

While the symphony has become a well-known work, the Menotti concerto does not deserve its obscurity. The download includes a doctoral dissertation on the work by Laura Tomlin that gives historical details and a detailed analysis.

The Symphony Hall sound, as usual, is quite good. I will have a few other early Menotti recordings up on the blog relatively soon.