And that was one of the main attractions of the RKO musical called The French Line, from 1953. As a reviewer on IMDb, who has seen the 3D version, writes, "When the posters outside of the theatre proclaimed 'JR in 3D!', they really meant what they said. During several musical numbers, when she would turn from profile and face the camera with her chest thrust out: watch out! You almost felt you should move away from the screen."
Of course, the soundtrack LP has no such advantages, and we are left with the vocalizations of Russell and Gilbert Roland. While both of them can sing, neither of them is a singer, if you catch the distinction. The songs here are by Josef Myrow (music) and the team of Ralph Blane and Robert Wells (lyrics). We have encountered Myrow here before with his songs for I Love Melvin. Blane is known for many films (Meet Me in St. Louis) and shows (Best Foot Forward). Wells' greatest hit was "The Christmas Song."
The results from this distinguished group are pleasant if hardly compelling. The best tune is probably "Wait Till You See Paris," but in this item Roland manages to be colorless and overwrought at the same time.
Oh well - it's a fairly rare LP, and I imagine connoisseurs of this kind of thing will enjoy the experience.
Note (July 2024) - This has now been remastered in ambient stereo.
Buster, Your covers and commentary are always great. I just saw Gentlemen Prefer Blondes so this should be a nice follow up. I like Jane Russell's singing. Sometimes it takes more than just a singer to get a song over, it can also actress to convey a song. On Youtube, there were some of her numbers that were quite compelling, even with the sound on.
ReplyDeleteThanks.
JohnnyUSA
Hi Johnny,
ReplyDeleteAgreed, she doesn't sing poorly - far from it. I'm not sure I would seek her out as a singer, though. She made quite a few records, including a good record with Sinatra (Kisses and Tears) and a gospel record called The Magic of Believing with Connie Haines and Beryl Davis. There are a couple of CD collections of these recordings.
Are you a magician or can you read minds? I searched your website recently to see if you had some Jane Russell !!! I finished reading her autobiography this week and wanted to hear more of her singing.
ReplyDeleteWell... whatever you do, thanks!!!
Well thanks, Ravel, but my skills don't extend to mind reading. We just have the same exceptional taste in women.
ReplyDeleteThanks! Too bad its a somewhat mediocre score, however I fully agree with what everyone here said about her singing abitlities. I like her. More than many "more professional" singers. @ JohnnyUSA: "... even with the sound on ..." LOL. Funny :-)
ReplyDeleteHer relaxed singing style made her such a perfect performer for Hoady Carmichael. Remember "When Loves Goes Wrong" with Marilyn? A real favourite of mine ...
Very nice. Circa 1977 Rose Records in Chicago (THE place to buy music in downtown Chicago, especially of the show tunes variety) still had new copies of this for sale. It was either the 45 box or the 10" LP and they had a copy in the racks, shrink wrapped on a piece of cardboard with a note to "ask at checkout counter" for a copy. Looking back I can't believe that I didn't buy one. The version of this movie that runs on TCM is the cleanest version (there were three release versions all told I believe) with Russell in long shot for the song "Looking for Trouble," notorious for Jane in a cleavage thrusting costume that really pissed off the prudes-hence the three versions. I've seen clips of the other versions but never the whole number. I've got a insert movie poster (thinner than a regular poster) with the "JR in 3-D" tagline along with "It'll Knock BOTH Your Eyes Out!" hanging in my stairwell.
ReplyDeleteOne more comment-if you're interested in the brouhaha surrounding the film check out the American Film Institute catalog notes section at TCM:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.tcm.com/tcmdb/title.jsp?stid=571&category=Notes
Thanks Eric - I think you'll find the uncut number on YouTube. She seems distinctly uncomfortable with the chest thrusts. (Perhaps she was afraid that she would poke BOTH your eyes out.)
ReplyDeleteBuster,
ReplyDeleteI'm looking for some rare tracks you might have. Do you have a contact email? Thanks.
@ pdlimm, If you leave your email here I will contact you.
ReplyDeletepeter[dot]limm[at]gmail.com
ReplyDeleteThanks, Buster!
I just cam across this site and absolutely love it.
ReplyDeleteUnfortunately several of the recordings you have posted are now unavailable like this one. Do you ever recycle the selections you've posted in the past?
Keep up the great work.
Mitch
Love to see many of the soundtracks that are no longer available come back as reposts along with the broadway material.
ReplyDeleteI'm new to both and have not seen many of the items you have here.
Thanks.
Thanks so much for this re-post.
ReplyDeleteI hope its just the first of your many great Soundtrack and Broadway items that are no longer available.
Mitch
Remastered version (Apple lossless):
ReplyDeletehttps://mega.co.nz/#!jdFWHRTT!TOGy5h9XjjOprcLRSRj6nFhSqtFjaa8ZxKBp2iA7m7U