16 September 2009

Hanson and Harris Symphonies


I promised a return to the America Festival Music Series that came from Rochester on Mercury records during the 1950s, so here we go with a notable pairing of symphonies. Howard Hanson and his Eastern-Rochester group present the work most often nominated as the "great American symphony" - Harris' third - with Hanson's own fourth.

The performance of the Harris is less muscular than you might be used to, if you are used to Leonard Bernstein's way with this music. I'm not complaining, just observing - I do prefer this approach. Hanson's symphony, meanwhile, is enjoyably Sibelian.

One of my favorite aspects of the LP (as often happens) is the American Scene-style cover, so appropriate in style if not in content for the Harris work. The cover artist (named Maas) may have been inspired by one of my favorite paintings in this style, John Rogers Cox's Gray and Gold from 1942.

The download includes the February 1955 review of this recording from The Gramophone, which observes that "one sometimes feels as though a guiding hand is reaching out to lead us into a particular section of the orchestra." If so, the guiding hand is Hanson's - these performances were recorded with a single microphone.

LINK - remastered in ambient stereo March 2025



5 comments:

Fred said...

Hi Buster,

I never get tired of the Harris 3rd and this is a good recording. Though Bernstein is number one with me, Hanson's smaller emsemble brings out some more of the detail then the larger NY Phil. Hanson's estimable contribution to American music speaks for itself.

Great work,

Fred

David Federman said...

Thanks for the Howard Hanson performance of the Roy Harris Third. It makes quite a contrast to the Serge Kousseviztky recording from 1939 which is more measured and grave. I admire both of them.

A request: In 1955, I remember buying an RCA 45 RPM set of Rolfe Lieberman's Concerto for Jazz Band & Orchestra performed by the Chicago Symphony Orchestra led by Fritz Reiner. Do you, by chance, have this rarity?

Buster said...

David,

I do have that Lieberman record, indeed.

coppinsuk said...

Hi Buster,

.....still trawling!

I just adore American artworks. I travel all over the US to see it. Was in Texas in February this year: Amon Carter, Houston, Stark, Remmington, Kincaid - some absolutely fabulous works of art, unknown to me and also Americans!

BUT, "John Rogers Cox's Gray and Gold from 1942" - never encountered before - just checked it out - so evocative of the mid-west. Although visited Cleveland and the art gallery (and much else, including CO concerts) over 30 year's ago do not recollect this painter, alas. Needs another visit.

Many thanks for this upload.

Cheers,

Douglas (UK)

Buster said...

I remember just where it used to be in the old museum layout. I have no idea where it is now, or if it even is on display. This kind of work is very out of fashion.